After the extreme close-up on the face, one of the most common shots in the Brothers Quay filmic grammar is the close-up on the hands. As these shots remind us, hands can be as expressive as faces, perhaps even more so, when it comes to conveying emotional states or revealing something about the person (or puppet) to whom they belong. Hands are also frequently agents of action in and of themselves and thus function as characters in some of the Quay’s films (cf the writing hands featured in an earlier post and gallery). As if to draw a parallel between the hands of puppets and their makers/masters, in at least one film – Rehearsals for Extinct Anatomies – we actually see one of the filmmakers’ hands as it reaches into the frame and sets a ball in motion, momentarily blurring the distinction between the narrative and meta levels of the film.
As if to emphasize their independent status, hands are frequently represented as autonomous entities in the Quays’ movies, moving about and acting on their own. In Stille Nacht III (1993), for example, the leading (actually, the only) roles are played by two disembodied hands. One guides us into and through the action of the film, floating down a dim hallway, pointing to the plaque indicating the locale (the apparently fictitious « Archiv Gottinga »), and then leading us to the place where the action will occur: a room housing an anamorphic deer table one of whose testicles will be grazed by a bullet fired by the other disembodied hand, the film being an illustration of the phenomenon by which the wounded or removed testicle of a deer results in the asymmetric growth of its antlers.
The use of the hand is more complex in The Comb (1990), where it performs several functions. Most noticeably perhaps, it serves as a leitmotif linking the film’s frame and embedded stories: the twitchy finger of the sleeping woman’s hand in the opening sequence foreshadows the wagging finger of the mysterious puppet that seems to reign over the puppet world. Each time the action moves from the frame story to the embedded story, the hand and twitching finger serve as the transition image. Also, within the puppet world, there is a child-like puppet carrying a ladder on “the edge of the forest,” as an intertitle tells us. At certain points, the puppet falls asleep on its feet and when it does so its hands become detached from its body and continue to carry the ladder on their own. Eventually, they bring the ladder into an ornate, wood-paneled, vault-like structure whose walls, decorated with calligraphed letters, are pierced by geometric openings that allow passage from one chamber into another. In one such chamber a woman puppet is sleeping, recalling the sleeping actress in the opening sequence of the film. Her presence suggests that the real and puppet worlds, and thus the frame and embedded narratives, are mirrors of one another, and that perhaps the sleeping woman in the frame story is dreaming of herself, asleep and dreaming in the embedded story.
And here things get complicated, since at one point the disembodied hands carrying the ladder through the vaulted space in which the woman puppet is sleeping push the ladder up and through her body from the inside, as if the space they were traveling through and which she herself inhabits is located within her, or that there is another such space inside her and within which another pair of disembodied hands carries a ladder, and another woman puppet sleeps, and so on, ad infinitum. Once free of her body the hands, still gripping the ladder, fly off and, as if on a magic carpet, sail through the vaulted space whose walls have since sprouted myriad ladders, some straight, some curved, which dangle downward like tree roots. Those hands eventually return to their place at the ends of the arms of the child puppet who awakens and continues on his way, and we eventually leave the puppet world for the “real” world via the transitional image of the hand with the wagging finger/the twitchy finger on the hand of the sleeping woman who finally awakens. She rises from her bed and begins her toilet as the film concludes, running her fingers through her hair, picking up a comb, combing her hair, then stopping to scrape her thumbnail across its teeth.
That comb had been presented in close-up at the beginning of the film, when it seemed to foreshadow the ladders that featured so prominently in the puppet world of the embedded story, its teeth suggesting their rungs. Appearing in close-up again at the end, it not only gives The Comb a strong sense of closure, it also emphasizes a motivic coherence in its suggestion of the ladders.
You can see a selection of the stills in the Brothers Quay gallery of hands.
·
- Zeitgeist Film’s Brothers Quay page
- Claire Kitson, “ANIMATED: On the Quays’ Side – ‘The Comb (from The Museums of Sleep)’”
- Picturing Writing (internal link)
- Brothers Quay gallery – writing (internal link)
·
Tagged: Brothers Quay, experimental film, hands, Stille Nacht III, The Comb





























